getting it on

..records of excitement and mundanity.. - politics - news - religion - sport - work - friends - family - stuff

My Photo
Name:
Location: Brisbane, Queensland, Australia

Sunday, March 08, 2009

Icelandic investment bankers and fishing

I haven't blogged in a while. I think I'm making an effort to reduce my online presence, but I've been doing a lot of reading lately and I think perhaps I could make this blog a little less about me, and more about things I've been learning, observed, and think about various topics.

So in that spirit, I've just read today a fascinating article about the collapse of the Icelandic economy, about what fishermen (fisherpeople?) and investment bankers have in common, and a small window into Icelandic culture.

Article: Wall Street on the Tundra

Here's a couple of extracts from the article that I either found very interesting, or made me laugh out loud:
Iceland instantly became the only nation on earth that Americans could point to and say, “Well, at least we didn’t do that.” In the end, Icelanders amassed debts amounting to 850 percent of their G.D.P. (The debt-drowned United States has reached just 350 percent.) As absurdly big and important as Wall Street became in the U.S. economy, it never grew so large that the rest of the population could not, in a pinch, bail it out.

Icelanders are among the most inbred human beings on earth—geneticists often use them for research.

Alcoa, the biggest aluminum company in the country, encountered two problems peculiar to Iceland when, in 2004, it set about erecting its giant smelting plant. The first was the so-called “hidden people”—or, to put it more plainly, elves—in whom some large number of Icelanders, steeped long and thoroughly in their rich folkloric culture, sincerely believe. Before Alcoa could build its smelter it had to defer to a government expert to scour the enclosed plant site and certify that no elves were on or under it. It was a delicate corporate situation, an Alcoa spokesman told me, because they had to pay hard cash to declare the site elf-free but, as he put it, “we couldn’t as a company be in a position of acknowledging the existence of hidden people.”

Back in 2001, as the Internet boom turned into a bust, M.I.T.’s Quarterly Journal of Economics published an intriguing paper called “Boys Will Be Boys: Gender, Overconfidence, and Common Stock Investment.” The authors, Brad Barber and Terrance Odean, gained access to the trading activity in over 35,000 households, and used it to compare the habits of men and women. What they found, in a nutshell, is that men not only trade more often than women but do so from a false faith in their own financial judgment. Single men traded less sensibly than married men, and married men traded less sensibly than single women: the less the female presence, the less rational the approach to trading in the markets.

What I've been thinking as well is that, even though I've believed in it for so long, perhaps the Milton Friedman dogmatism for free markets just isn't the solution. I still believe in the market, but because the assumptions for free markets are virtually never met, why should policies be created to support this ideal? And this backflip in the capitalist zeitgeist is being supported at the very highest eschalons; for example, former US Federal Reserve Chairman, Alan Greenspan (who is a known libertarian), now supports the part nationalisation of banks. Which really could only be expected based on what is happening in the world economy at present.

I would have to stop, however, at calling myself a neo-keynesian. Last month I read the article that Kevin Rudd published in the magazine called "Monthly", and how the neo-liberal movement is the reason behind the worldwide economic crisis, and how neo-keynesian and social democratic policies are going to save the day. And as surprisingly impressed I was by the article, and how article and persuasive it was, I still don't entirely buy it. In contrast to the common quote "we're all Keynesians now", I most certainly am not, but no longer belief that deregulated capitalist markets are a sustainable solution.

Social democratic ideals aren't going to serve as a white knight that rescues us all from ourselves. I still believe in minimal government, but adequate regulation for the market to not cannibalise itself. And it has to be recognised when something can't be privatised: for example, when something is a public good.

What I really don't believe is that government has a better idea of how to manage enterprise, spending, and the economy than non-public corporations. A corporations' objective is mostly ubiquitous and transparent: maximise shareholder wealth. What is the government's objective? Well that depends on the government. Do they want to be green? Do they want to go to war and invest in military spending? Do they want to encourage a social democracy? Or do they want to encourage business and corporation?

I think the real role of the government is to manage public goods and create adequate legal infrastructure for the markets to operate - the legal infrastructure being necessary to ensure the market doesn't canabalise itself.

So I came across another interesting idea yesterday: libertarian socialism. Sounds like a bit of a paradox in terms, but the basic idea (because that's about the level of my understanding at present), involves liberal policies of minimal government in order to decentralise the influence of any one body (usually government). Any economically significant property should not be privately owned, but run by a body that is the equivalent of a union so that people have direct democratic rights to the means of production. It's actually quite closely tied to anarchism. I really don't know enough about it to comment on whether I agree or not. My first reaction was to disagree (letting go of long time neo-liberalist beliefs is a difficult thing), but someone I know is reading up on Noam Chomsky, a well-respected thinker in the libertarian socialist field, and I'm sure he'll be able to further explain when he does the reading.

Labels: , , ,

Sunday, June 15, 2008

I've been doing my head in trying to get my head around some macroeconomic models. In particular the aggregate expenditure models, aggregate demand and aggregate supply models, multipliers, twin deficits hypothesis, etc, etc. My textbooks do nothing short of (virtually) inducing me to bang my head against a wall.

I've found a website that called AmosWEB that although doesn't have all the information I want, it has a really good break down on the Keynesian models, broken down in a pretty intuitive and easy to understand way. Unfortunately it's an American, not an Australian resource, but hey - if it breaks it down so I can understand it, I can't really be too critical.

Wikipedia as usual, also helps, but not quite to the same extent as usual.

So back to the books. Very much stressing out.

Labels: ,

Monday, June 09, 2008

Some of the government policies leave a bit to be desired

I was reading this article today about Australian's being worse off, and I found myself pretty bemused by the following comment by a certain gentleman in Glenwood, NSW:

worse off ? bloody worse off alright Posted by: ash, glenwood nsw, on 9/06/2008 1:03:55 PM

i always knew john howard should have stayed in government. Australia was very stable when he was right up there. Alright workchoices wasnt the best of ideas but the little things he did to get our economy up. I have heard about LABOR'S past and belive that it will all happen all over agen with little kevin rudd penis boy making trips to japan and every bloddy where else he isnt even here to see that petrol prices go down little knob face

I think what has amused me the most is the incoherent inclusion of the terms "knob face" and "penis boy".

And despite the fact that the comment really isn't the most eloquently written statement, I daresay I agree with him.

I think I've tried to find the good points in the current Labor party's direction. The 2020 Summit was a good idea. Thinking about the future is a good idea. The bionic eye reasearch - a good idea - but not exactly a new idea, considering that the research for it is already in its very final stages. The promotion of Australian arts - a good idea - pity that anything that pushes the boundaries (such as Bill Henson's works) gets classes as "revolting" by our Prime Minister. Signing the Kyoto Protocol - a very good idea. There's no two ways about that one. I have this feeling that I once said that I didn't think it was all that meaningful. So if I did say that, I'm officially eating my words on that one.

I recently did an economics essay on why markets fail, and I used climate change as the case study. Climate change, according to Nicholas Stern, is the "greatest and widest-ranging market failure ever seen" (if you're interested in reading the Exec Summary of the Stern Report - and it's actually not a bad read - you can get to it here).

If I can approve of the Rudd government for any reason, it's for that alone. For me, that mitigates a whole pile of the other fairly mediocre things he's doing/done.

My examples continue:
Raising the medicare levy threshold to $100 000 for singles and $150 000 for couples - not a good idea. A PriceWaterhouseCoopers (PWC) report on the effects of the increased Medicare surcharge said that approximately 1 million people will now opt out of private health insurance, having a flow-on effect of placing more burden on the public health system and hospitals, as well as making private health insurers need to increase their prices to cover costs. Wayne Swan (the little tosspot that he is), outrightly rejected the PWC report, saying that "Treasury has done its modelling". One would think that the Treasurer of the country would want to try to look a little deeper into why there was such a discrepancy in figures, rather than blindly saying that he was right. As it transpires, Treasury did not include children or dependents in their modelling; if it had, it would have come to a similar conclusion of approximately 1 million people as the PWC report had. I'm not sure how the states are going to be compensated to cope with the increased demand for public hospitals.

Alcopops tax - one of the more brainless taxes I've ever heard of. Increasing the price of a good, leads to an increase in demand for its substitutes. Extremely basic economic theory. Example: what would an 18 year old do when they're going to a party and they want to drink a vodka cruiser, but they're too expensive? What I would do is go halves on a bottle of vodka with my mate and buy a bottle of softdrink. So does an alcopops tax stop the teen binge drinking problem? No, I don't think so. Effectively it's just another tax that the government has implemented, but not really thought through (at all).

Luxury car tax - again, not the best idea. And funnily enough, the Labor government might have conceded this one. It's basically not a smart idea for a couple of reasons:
1) It's a blanket tax on cars that cost $57,123 or more. This includes cars that are bought by large families and people in wheelchairs, aka people movers. It's not a tax that helps the people he wants to help.
2) It's a tax on a tax. As it currently exists, cars have a 10% GST on them, and are charged a 25% tax on top of that. The Rudd government's proposition in their budget was to raise this tax from 25% to 33%. In an economic sense, taxes result in something called a dead-weight loss, because it reduces consumer and producer welfare, and welfare is effectively "lost" due to the taxes - as in the loss of producer/consumer welfare doesn't get transferred anywhere else (sorry - in economics mode at the moment because I'm studying for my exam :-P).

And lastly (because I really should be getting back to the books now), is the Fuel Watch scheme. To be honest, I don't really know enough about this one to argue that it's a good or a bad thing. Intrinsically, I think that the transparency of petrol prices is a good thing. It leads to a freer and more open market, and less information asymmetries. However, that would only be the case if the petrol producers existed in a more competitive environment. Basically because there's only a few big players (an oligopoly), they really can control the prices. I daresay if they can monitor the prices of the little guys, they can squeeze them out of business, because they can sustainably run at lower than cost prices if need be (for a while at least), while the little guys can't afford to do that. You may say that that's anti-competitive behaviour, and they'll get in trouble for it, but I also think that no one is going to complain to the ACCC for a fuel company keeping their petrol prices low.


To show that I'm not grossly biased, I can't help but try to throw in a couple of good things too.

Good things:
- The tax review. Hopefully it'll make the government get rid of some of their more ridiculous taxes.
- The idea from the 2020 Summit to allow students to reduce their HECS debt by doing community service. I really think that is a super idea. Hopefully the government will create a budget for that.

Labels: , , , , , , , ,